High-value home insurance: Coverage, carriers, and costs for luxury homes

What is considered a high-value home for insurance?

A high-value home for insurance purposes generally has $750,000 or more in dwelling coverage (replacement cost), though some insurers define high-value homes as those with $1 million or more in replacement cost coverage.

The market value of a home is not the same as its replacement cost. Replacement cost is the estimated amount it would take to rebuild the home with similar materials and craftsmanship at current construction prices. Market value reflects what the property could sell for, including the land, location, and local real estate demand. As a result, the two figures can differ significantly. 

A $2 million home in a high-demand market may have a replacement cost of $1.2 million. A $900,000 home with custom features may have a replacement cost of $1.4 million. 

Features that indicate a need for high-value home insurance include custom construction or rare materials, significant square footage, high-value personal property such as art, jewelry, wine collections, and features that increase liability risk, like a pool, home staff, or multiple structures on the property.

Insurance coverage is based on the cost to rebuild the home, not on what the property could sell for. Insurers use the dwelling's replacement cost to determine eligibility for high-value homeowners insurance rather than the home's purchase price or market value.

High-value home insurance vs. standard home insurance

High-value home insurance offers broader protection than a standard HO-3 policy, primarily by providing enhanced rebuilding coverage that exceeds the home's insured dwelling limit after a covered loss.

“In general, high net worth policies are going to have a variety of coverage enhancements built into the base form that offer additional layers of protection, including guaranteed replacement cost and higher sublimits on unscheduled items such as jewelry, coins and collectible items,” said Scott Schuler, senior vice president of personal lines with Cincinnati Insurance. "Many high-net-worth policies also include identity theft and water backup up to the policy limits.”

Which companies offer high-value home insurance?

Specialty high-net-worth (HNW) insurers include Chubb, AIG Private Client Select, PURE, Cincinnati Financial, and Openly. Some traditional insurers also insure expensive homes, although their policies may not include the same specialized HNW features; these policies are usually HO-5, or comprehensive form, coverage.

While traditional carriers, like State Farm, Allstate, Farmers, and Progressive, provide coverage for high-value homes through customized HO-3 or HO-5 policies, they may not offer the specialty HNW policy features.

Additionally, several mass-market carriers have exited or restricted writing in wildfire and hurricane zones in California and Florida, pushing high-value homeowners in those states toward specialty carriers or the E&S market.

How much does high-value home insurance cost by state?

High-value home insurance from traditional insurers ranges from $2,181 in Hawaii to $20,711 in Florida for $1 million. However, rates vary by dwelling value and location-based catastrophe risk exposure.

The table below shows average home insurance rates by state from traditional insurers who offer high-value home coverage through HO-3 policies, with available endorsements to expand coverage.

Premiums vary significantly based on factors like roof age and material, construction type, proximity to fire station, presence of pool or other attractive nuisances, claims history at the address, and credit score (where allowed by state).

What does high-value home insurance cover?

High-value home insurance generally includes guaranteed dwelling replacement costs, extensive personal property coverage, and a cash settlement option after a total loss. Standard policies generally have lower coverage limits and fewer options.

High-value home insurance typically includes:

• Guaranteed or extended replacement cost on the dwelling. Pays to rebuild the home, even if the costs exceed your dwelling limit, after a covered loss. The protection is especially valuable after a widespread disaster, since labor shortages and material prices can rise significantly. Standard policies leave homeowners responsible for the rebuilding costs above their coverage limit. 
• Open perils coverage on personal property at replacement cost. Coverage for personal belongings that reimburses at replacement cost if anything happens to the items. Standard homeowners policies usually cover personal property for named perils only, and at actual cash value (depreciated) unless an endorsement is added.
• Cash settlement option after total loss. Allows homeowners to receive a cash settlement after a covered total loss, rather than rebuilding the home. Standard policies require that a home be rebuilt or repaired, with no cash option. 
• Higher liability limits and umbrella integration. High-value home insurance policies typically start with at least $1 million in personal liability coverage and integrate with umbrella policies offering higher coverage. Standard home policies usually have liability limits of $100,000-$500,000, which may not be enough for homeowners with greater lawsuit exposure.
• Private flood insurance above the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) cap. Some high-value home insurers offer private flood insurance with limits exceeding the NFIP cap, providing more comprehensive coverage for expensive properties. Standard home insurance excludes flood damage, and most homeowners must purchase a separate NFIP or private flood policy for protection. 
• Concierge claims service with a dedicated adjuster. High-value insurers may assign specialized adjusters and offer concierge-style service to handle coordinating repairs and restoration. Standard insurers offer traditional claims handling without dedicated adjusters or specialized service. 
• Scheduled personal property coverage for art, jewelry, and collections. Insurers offer higher coverage limits for expensive personal property. Standard home insurance policies offer low sublimits that can leave expensive property underinsured without additional endorsements.
• Identity theft and cyber coverage. Some high-value home insurers include identity theft and cyber protection in policies, but others make them available through endorsements. Standard homeowners insurance rarely includes these coverages.

How high-value home insurance coverage differs from a standard policy by feature

High-value home insurance costs more than a standard homeowners policy because it provides higher coverage limits, broader protections, and specialized benefits designed for expensive homes and assets, such as guaranteed replacement cost coverage.

“Having extended or guaranteed replacement cost options is important as building costs are constantly in flux. Having guaranteed replacement cost means your carrier will rebuild your home to its original size, style, and quality after a covered loss – even if that cost exceeds policy limits,” said Schuler. 

What happens to high-value homeowners in difficult markets?

A difficult market for a high-value homeowner means standard carriers are nonrenewing policies, such as State Farm and Allstate in California, carriers tightening eligibility in highest-hazard ZIP codes, and homeowners being pushed toward the Excess and Surplus (E&S) market or state Fair Access to Insurance Requirements (FAIR) Plans.

Options available to high-value homeowners who cannot obtain coverage include:

• E&S market carriers like Vault and Berkley One. These specialty insurers cover homes that standard insurers decline, such as luxury properties in wildfire- or hurricane-prone areas. However, policies often cost more and may have different coverage terms.
• FAIR Plan plus a Difference in Conditions (DIC) wrap policy. Many California homeowners combine the FAIR Plan's basic fire coverage with a DIC wrap policy from a private insurer to restore coverage for liability, theft, water damage, and other perils excluded by the FAIR Plan. The trade-off is managing two separate policies with different deductibles, exclusions, and claims processes. 
• Private flood insurance for coastal homes above the NFIP cap. Owners of expensive homes along the coast or in floodplains can often purchase private flood insurance with limits that exceed the NFIP's maximum residential building coverage. However,  underwriting, pricing, and availability vary significantly by location and flood risk, and coverage is not guaranteed.
• Risk mitigation investments. Insurers may reconsider homes that previously failed underwriting if the owner completes mitigation projects such as installing a fire-resistant roof and creating defensible space. However, these improvements can require substantial upfront investment and do not guarantee acceptance or lower premiums.

How to get high-value home insurance

To get high-value home insurance, determine how much it will cost to replace your home, collect documentation, and compare quotes from at least two HNW insurers.

1. Determine your home's replacement cost. Your home’s replacement cost may be significantly higher than market value and must be calculated before approaching carriers, as this determines eligibility and the correct coverage amount. 
2. Work with an independent agent who specializes in high-net-worth clients. Most high-net-worth (HNW) carriers, like Chubb, PURE, and Cincinnati, don't sell policies directly to consumers, so you'll need to get a quote through an independent insurance agent. 
3. Gather documentation before the underwriting process. You’ll need a home appraisal, an inventory of high-value personal property with appraisals for art and jewelry, and records of recent renovations to determine how much coverage you need. 
4. Understand the underwriting inspection process. Many high-value home insurers inspect the property before issuing a policy, either through an in-person visit or by reviewing aerial or satellite imagery to evaluate the home's condition and potential risks. 
5. Compare at least two HNW carriers. Get quotes from at least two high-value home insurers using the same coverage limits and deductibles so you can compare the policies fairly, not just the premiums.

Glossary: Key high-value home insurance terms

• Guaranteed replacement cost: Coverage that pays the full cost to rebuild your home to its original condition after a covered loss, even if rebuilding costs exceed your policy's dwelling coverage limit. This protection helps ensure you can fully rebuild after a major disaster, even if labor and material costs rise unexpectedly.
• Extended replacement cost: Coverage that increases your dwelling coverage limit by a specified percentage when rebuilding costs exceed the original limit after a covered loss. It provides a financial cushion but has a maximum payout.
• Cash settlement option: Policy feature that allows you to receive a cash payout instead of rebuilding your home after a covered loss. This gives you the flexibility to buy another home, rebuild elsewhere, or use the money for another purpose.
• Open perils coverage: Coverage that protects your property against all causes of loss unless the policy specifically excludes them. High-value insurance policies usually provide this coverage for personal property.
• Actual cash value: Pays claims based on the value of the damaged property minus depreciation. The payment reflects the item's current value rather than the cost to replace it, so you may have to pay out of pocket to buy a new replacement.
• Replacement cost value: Pays the cost to repair or replace damaged property with new property of a similar kind and quality without deducting for depreciation. This coverage typically has a higher claim payment than actual cash value.
• Excess and Surplus (E&S) market: Specialty insurance companies that insure homes and other properties standard insurers won't cover because of higher or unusual risks. High-value homeowners often turn to the E&S market after being declined or non-renewed by traditional insurers, especially in wildfire- or hurricane-prone areas. 
• Difference in Conditions (DIC) policy: Supplemental insurance that fills coverage gaps left by another policy, such as a California FAIR Plan policy. It commonly adds protection for risks like theft, liability, water damage, and other covered perils that the FAIR Plan does not include.
• Scheduled personal property: Coverage that insures valuable items, like jewelry, fine art, antiques, or collectibles, for their appraised value. Scheduling valuables provides broader protection and higher coverage limits than the standard sublimits included in most homeowners policies.
• High-net-worth (HNW) carrier: An insurer that specializes in covering expensive homes, valuable possessions, and affluent households. They usually offer broader coverage, higher limits, specialized claims service, and risk management resources.
• Dwelling coverage threshold: The minimum replacement cost a home must have before an insurer considers it eligible for a high-value home insurance policy. Most insurers set this threshold between $750,000 and $1 million in dwelling replacement cost, although the exact amount varies by carrier.

Helpful home insurance tools and calculators

• Home insurance calculator
• Condo insurance calculator
• Renters insurance calculator
• When to file a home insurance claim