Go To Top

Gap insurance is designed to protect automobile owners if their car is totaled or stolen. But gap insurance is not cheap. The average cost of gap insurance in Indiana is $1,508 per year, according to a 2022 rate analysis by Insurance.com.

Gap insurance pays the difference between the amount you owe on a car loan and the car's actual cash value – which could prove extremely valuable if you owe more on your car than it is worth. To be eligible for gap insurance, car owners must have comprehensive and collision coverage on their auto insurance policy.

Apart from protecting you financially, gap insurance can provide peace of mind in case something happens to your car.

Keep reading to get more insights on gap insurance in Indiana.

Check out our guide: Gap insurance for your new or leased cars.

How does gap insurance work?

Gap insurance pays the difference between what your car is worth and what you owe on your car loan if your vehicle is stolen or totaled. It doesn't pay to get a new or replacement vehicle. Instead, it ensures that you don't have to continue payments on a car that is a total loss.

To better understand how gap insurance works, let’s look at an example.

Assume you bought a car worth $25,000. You get into an accident and your vehicle is totaled. But you still owe $20,000 to your lender. When you file a claim, your insurer will pay the actual cash value of your car, which is, say, $19,000. Even after the insurer pays for the actual cash value of your car, there remains an outstanding loan amount of $1,000.

Now, if you do not have gap insurance coverage, you will be required to pay the remaining $1,000 of the loan. On the other hand, gap insurance will pay for any remaining loan balance.

The table below spells this out in detail:

Worth of the car$25,000
Loan amount left to be paid$20,000
The amount the insurer pays your lender (actual cash value of your car)$19,000
Amount still due on the loan, after insurance claim payout$1,000
With gap coverageThe driver will pay off the loan without any money out of pocket
Without gap coverageThe driver will have $1,000 out of pocket to pay off the loan.

Learn more: Can I cancel gap insurance coverage?

Cheapest gap insurance companies in Indiana

Nationwide tops the list of the cheapest car insurance companies that provide gap insurance in Indiana, at about $1,132 per year, on average.Travelers is second on the list followed by American Family Insurance.

Below is the list of the car insurance companies offering cheap gap insurance in Indiana, along with their average annual rates.

CompanyAverage Insurance Rates
Nationwide$1,132
Travelers$1,228
American Family Insurance$1,312
Auto-Owners$1,372
Progressive$1,707

How much does gap insurance cost in Indiana?

The average gap insurance rate in Indiana is $1,508 per year, according to a rate analysis by Insurance.com.

The cost of gap insurance depends on factors like the value of your car, the car insurance company you choose, your location, and your age. Hence, it is a good idea to compare quotes from at least three insurance providers before making the final decision.

Average gap insurance rates in Indiana by City

In Indiana, gap insurance rates differ from one city to another, as insurers consider different factors such as an area’s frequency of theft, collisions, and vandalism, while calculating the rates. These factors can help insurers accurately predict the potential for claims.

Gap insurance rates are the cheapest in Granger, Indiana, at $1,227 per year, or $102.25 per month. On the other hand, Gary has the most expensive gap insurance rates at $2,322 per year, or $194 per month. The table below lists the gap insurance costs for some cities in Indiana:

CityAverage Annual Rates
Granger$1,227
Bloomington$1,267
Fort Wayne$1,269
Griffin$1,405
Burns Harbor$1,450
Dyer$1,466
Lawrence$1,499
Munster$1,505
Indianapolis$1,670
Gary$2,322

Read up on can you get a gap insurance refund for more details.

How much does gap insurance cost by age in Indiana?

The cost of gap insurance varies by age. For example, in Indiana, a 20-year-old driver can expect to pay about $3,474 per year for gap insurance, while a 30-year-old driver would pay closer to $1,621 per year for the same coverage.

Young drivers are considered riskier as they lack driving experience on the road. Their chances of getting into an accident are four times higher than that of more mature drivers. Therefore, their rates are higher to begin with. So, if you're a young driver in Indiana, you'll probably pay more for gap insurance than an older driver.

The table below lists gap insurance costs based on age in Indiana:

AgeAverage Annual Rates
20$3,474
30$1,621
40$1,493
70$1,524

FAQs

Is gap insurance required in Indiana?

Gap insurance is optional coverage in Indiana. But if you have a lease or loan agreement your lender will most likely require you to purchase gap insurance. But you can drop the coverage as soon as your car loan becomes lower than the value of your car.

Who should buy gap insurance in Indiana?

Those who have their car on lease or loan should consider purchasing gap insurance in Indiana to financially protect themselves.

Apart from that, it is considered a good idea to purchase gap insurance in Indiana if:

  • You have paid only 20% of your auto loan
  • You have financed a car for more than 60 months (five years)
  • You lease your vehicle

Also keep in mind depreciation. A new car drops in value about 20% in the first year of ownership and loses more than 10% of its value each year over the next four years, according to information on car-history site Carfax.com. This means that the payout you would get for the value of the car is likely to be much less than what you owe for at least the first several years.

Where to buy gap insurance in Indiana?

Here is where you can purchase gap insurance in Indiana:

  • From your car insurance company
  • From a company offering stand-alone gap insurance policies
  • From your car dealer
  • From the bank/financial institution which offered you a loan for purchasing your car

As the rates vary from one insurance provider to another, it is advised to compare quotes from multiple sources before making the purchase.

Methodology

Insurance.com gathered data with the help of Quadrant Information Services from major insurance companies across Indiana that offer gap insurance. We included rates for drivers aged 20, 30, 40, and 70. All rates are based on the profile of a driver with a clean record and full coverage policy.

The coverage limit for a full coverage policy is 100/300/100 liability with a $500 comprehensive and collision deductible. The numbers 100/300/100 represent:

  • $100,000 coverage for bodily injury per person
  • $300,000 in bodily injury per accident
  • $100,000 for property damage

Sources: