Which pays first auto insurance or health insurance?

When there are injuries in a car accident, the medical bills get complicated in a hurry. The laws in your state and who is at fault for the accident will largely determine which insurance company pays.

As a general rule, auto insurance is the primary insurance for accident-related injuries. That means the auto insurance company pays first and health insurance pays any remaining bills.

However, which portion of your policy pays and how long that takes depends on the situation.

Does it matter who is at fault for the accident?

If you live in a no-fault state where you must carry personal injury protection (PIP), that coverage will be primary after a car accident. You’ll file the claim with your car insurance company directly. Your health insurance, in this case, would be secondary to the PIP coverage.

“In an at-fault accident, the only coverage for bodily injury afforded under your automobile policy that you would have is medical payments and PIP, if applicable. If you're not at fault, then you still need to see if medical payments and PIP, if applicable, is coverage that is on your automobile policy, as these coverages pay regardless of fault,” says Paul Moss, founder and CEO at HeyDriver,! an online insurance agency.

However, in a fault (tort) state, the fault in an accident does matter. If you’re at fault, neither your policy nor the other driver’s policy is responsible for your medical bills (unless you have chosen to add PIP or medical payments coverage as an option.)

The other driver’s liability insurance will be on the hook for your bills if you're not at fault. However, getting that money can take some time, as even determining fault can be a lengthy process.

“If you are not at fault, your health insurance will pay the upfront expenses and then subrogate (recoup) their payments from the auto insurance of the at-fault party's auto policy liability. You should always check with your automobile company to see if you have medical payments or PIP (if applicable) coverage, which pays out regardless of fault and can cover any copays or deductibles that may apply with your health insurance plan,” Moss says.

Who pays the medical bills if the other driver is uninsured?

If the other driver is at fault but doesn’t have insurance, there are a few options to pay for your injuries.

First, if you have PIP, it will pay regardless of fault. Second, if you have uninsured motorist coverage, you can look to that coverage to pay your bills.

If neither of those coverages is available, your health insurance will pay your bills. You may consider suing the at-fault driver, but unfortunately, drivers without insurance aren’t likely to have the means to pay a judgment. That leaves one of your insurance plans as the payee.

Does going to urgent care instead of the emergency room affect insurance?

You don’t have to go to the ER if you aren’t severely injured. However, there are a few things to remember when deciding between the emergency room or urgent care.

An emergency room can’t refuse to treat anyone in need of care, regardless of whether they have insurance. That’s true regardless of whether car or health insurance is expected to pay the bill.

Urgent care clinics, on the other hand, don’t have the same rules. While most will see you regardless, accident victims have been turned away. Why? The clinic either isn’t set up to bill a car insurance company, or the health system has rules against working with third-party insurance (car insurance is the third party in this case).

The clinic doesn’t want to wait for the car accident settlement to get paid for treating you. When this is the case, you may be sent to the emergency room even if your injuries don’t warrant it, resulting in a higher bill.

Health insurance finder tool

Are you unemployed and lost your job within the past 60 days?
lady with box
Back
Can you get health insurance from your job?
Back
men use laptop
Back
Do you have spouse who can get health insurance through a job?
Back
couple
Back
What is your age?
Back
three mens
Back Reset result
Our recommendation

COBRA

Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act
People who lose their employer-sponsored health insurance may qualify for a COBRA plan. COBRA lets you keep your former employer's health plan, but you're responsible for paying all of the costs, including your former employer's portion.
Know more about COBRA
You can also opt for
Back Reset result
Our recommendation blue shield
Back Reset result

How much is your family income?

$1,000 $100,000

How big is your family?

Back
family
Back Reset result
Our recommendation

Medicare

People who are 65 and over qualify for Medicare. You can choose Original Medicare (also called Parts A and B), which is offered by the federal government, or Medicare Advantage (also called Part C), which private insurers provide. The average annual premium for Original Medicare is about $1,600. Medicare Advantage's average yearly premium is $336, but you may have higher out-of-pocket costs than Original Medicare.
Find out more about Medicare costs
Back Reset result
Our recommendation blue shield
family
Compare and Buy Health Insurance Quotes in minutes
Back Reset result
Our recommendation

Medicaid

Low-income Americans qualify for Medicaid. Thirty-eight states expanded Medicaid eligibility, so lower-middle-class Americans may also be eligible in those states. Medicaid offers comprehensive benefits, but at little to no cost depending on your income. Each state has its own eligibility. Some states are flexible with Medicaid eligibility for people who are pregnant, a parent or disabled. If your household income is below 138% of the federal poverty level, you're likely eligible for Medicaid if you live in a Medicaid expansion state. That level is $17,609 for an individual, $23,791 for a family of two, $29,974 for a family of three and $36,156 for a family of four. Non-Medicare expansion states have stricter income guidelines. Check with your state's Medicaid program to see if you qualify.
You can also opt for
Back Reset result
Our recommendation blue shield
family
Compare and Buy Health Insurance Quotes in minutes
Back Reset result
Our recommendation

Parent's employer-based health insurance

The Affordable Care Act lets children stay on a parent's health plan until the age of 26. Having a child on a parent's health plan may or may not increase premiums. It depends on whether you already have family coverage when adding the child to the plan. If a parent already has family coverage, adding a child won't likely increase premiums. However, going from single or couple to family coverage could cause premiums to skyrocket. The average single coverage employer-sponsored plan premium is $1,186. The average family plan is $5,447.
You can also opt for
Back Reset result
Our recommendation blue shield
Back Reset result
Our recommendation

Spouse's employer-based health insurance

Most employers allow employees to add spouses to their health insurance. Going from single health coverage to a family plan may triple or quadruple your premiums. The average single coverage employer-sponsored plan premium is $1,186. The average family plan is $5,447. Not all jobs allow for spouse's coverage, so you'll want to check with your employer to make sure it's an option.
You can also opt for
Back Reset result
Our recommendation blue shield
Find out more about
  • PPO
  • HMO
  • HDHP
  • EPO
Back Reset result
Our recommendation

Employer-based health insurance

Most people with private health insurance get their coverage through a job. employer-sponsored health insurance is usually cheaper than individual health insurance unless you qualify for Affordable Care Act subsidies. Job-based plans are generally less expensive because businesses often pick up more than half of employer-sponsored health insurance premiums. Kaiser Family Foundation estimates the average premiums for a single coverage employer-sponsored health plan is $1,186 and the average family plan is $5,447 annually.
You can also opt for
Back Reset result
Our recommendation blue shield
Click to each one of find out more
  • PPO
  • HMO
  • HDHP
  • EPO
Back Reset result
Employer plans are often one of these types of four plans. Click on each one to find out more.
  • PPO
  • HMO
  • HDHP
  • EPO

Preferred-provider Organization (PPOs)

  • Pay higher premiums with a lower deductible
  • You have access to more providers, but pay much more for health insurance
  • You don't want to choose a primary care physician
  • You don't want to get a referral
  • You want the ability to get out-of-network care
Preferred-provider organization (PPOs) plans are the most common type of employer-based health plan. PPOs have higher premiums than HMOs and HDHPs, but those added costs offer you flexibility. A PPO allows you to get care anywhere and without primary care provider referrals. You may have to pay more to get out-of-network care, but a PPO will pick up a portion of the costs.
Find out more about the differences between plans

Health maintenance organization (HMO)

  • Pay higher premiums with a lower deductible
  • Restricted network of providers with lower premiums
  • You want to choose a primary care physician
  • You don't mind getting a referral
  • You don't care about the ability to get out-of-network care
Health maintenance organization (HMO) plans have lower premiums than PPOs. However, HMOs have more restrictions. HMOs don't allow you to get care outside of your provider network. If you get out-of-network care, you'll likely have to pay for all of it. HMOs also require you to get primary care provider referrals to see specialists.
Find out more about the differences between plans

High-deductible health plans (HDHPs)

  • Pay lower premiums with a higher deductible
High-deductible health plans (HDHPs) have become more common as employers look to reduce their health costs. HDHPs have lower premiums than PPOs and HMOs, but much higher deductibles. A deductible is what you have to pay for health care services before your health plan chips in money. Once you reach your deductible, the health plan pays a portion and you pay your share, which is called coinsurance.
Find out more about the differences between plans

Exclusive provider organization (EPO)

  • Restricted network of providers with lower premiums
  • You don't want to choose a primary care physician
  • You don't want to get a referral
  • You don't care about the ability to get out-of-network care
Exclusive provider organization (EPO) plans offer the flexibility of a PPO with the restricted network found in an HMO. EPOs don't require that members get a referral to see a specialist. In that way, it's similar to a PPO. However, an EPO requires in-network care, which is like an HMO.
Find out more about the differences between plans
Back Reset result
green shield
family
Compare and Buy Health Insurance Quotes in minutes
Back Reset result
Individual insurance/Affordable Care Act
The Affordable Care Act created insurance exchanges that allow people to compare plans. The health law also requires insurers to accept everyone and not charge them exorbitant rates. People who make below 400% of the federal poverty level qualify for subsidies to help pay for an ACA plan.
Know more individual insurance / ACA
Back Reset result
blue shield
To find the kind of ACA plan for you, would you rather...
Back Reset result
Individual insurance/Affordable Care Act
The Affordable Care Act created insurance exchanges that allow people to compare plans. The health law also requires insurers to accept everyone and not charge them exorbitant rates. People who make below 400% of the federal poverty level qualify for subsidies to help pay for an ACA plan.
Know more individual insurance / ACA
People who would prefer to pay lower premiums with a higher deductible may want the below plans
Back Reset result
silver shield

Silver is the second most popular plan in the ACA exchanges, with 35% of people with a Silver plan. Silver has lower premiums than any plan except for Bronze. However, it has lower out-of-pocket costs than Bronze. Silver plans pick up 70% of the costs, while members pay 30% The average single coverage in a Silver plan is $481 monthly and $1,179 for a family plan.

Bronze is the most popular type of plan in the ACA exchanges, with 41% of members with a Bronze plan. These plans have the lowest premiums, but also the highest out-of-pocket costs in the exchanges. Bronze plans pick up 60% of the costs, while members pay 40%. The average single coverage monthly cost in a Bronze plan is $440 and $1,080 for a family plan.

family
Compare and Buy Health Insurance Quotes in minutes
Back Reset result
Individual insurance/Affordable Care Act
The Affordable Care Act created insurance exchanges that allow people to compare plans. The health law also requires insurers to accept everyone and not charge them exorbitant rates. People who make below 400% of the federal poverty level qualify for subsidies to help pay for an ACA plan.
Know more individual insurance / ACA
People who would prefer to pay higher premiums with a lower deductible may want the below plans
Back Reset result
platinum shield

Platinum plans have the highest premiums but the lowest out-of-pocket costs. So, you pay more for the coverage initially but less than other plans when you need health care services. Platinum plans pick up 90% of the costs, while members pay 10%, Not many health insurers offer Platinum plans. Only 2% of members in ACA plans have a Platinum plan, so you may have trouble finding one. The average monthly premiums for single coverage in a Platinum plan is $706 and the average family coverage costs $1,460.

Gold plans have lower premiums than Platinum, but higher premiums than Silver and Bronze. Gold also has lower out-of-pocket costs than Silver and Bronze, but higher than Platinum. Gold plans pick up 80% of the costs, while members pay 20%. The average monthly premium for a single Gold plan is $596. Family coverage averages $1,426 per month.

family
Compare and Buy Health Insurance Quotes in minutes

How can you get help with insurance billing after an accident?

Depending on the situation, you may reach out to several sources of assistance to deal with accident bills. First, if you have an insurance agent, you can start there to get questions answered. Your insurance adjuster can also help.

If you get your health insurance through work, you may have someone in HR who can help you make sense of bills and speak with the insurance company on your behalf. To get help dealing with uncooperative car insurance companies, you can contact your state’s insurance department.

Finally, you may need to hire a lawyer, especially if there are questions of fault or when there are a lot of medical bills that may exceed an at-fault driver’s limits.

Continue reading