- Average car insurance cost in Brookhaven
- Cheapest car insurance companies in Brookhaven
- Cheapest car insurance cost in Brookhaven by age group
- Cheapest car insurance companies in Brookhaven by driver profile
- Car insurance discounts for Brookhaven drivers
- How to get cheap car insurance in Brookhaven in 2025
- Methodology
- Compare auto insurance rates by city in Pennsylvania
Average car insurance cost in Brookhaven
The average car insurance rate in Brookhaven for full coverage is $2,782 per year or $232 a month. These rates are for coverage levels of 100/300/100 with $500 deductibles.
Whereas, the average rate for state minimum coverage in Brookhaven is $608 per year. The state minimum liability limits are 15/30/5.
Full coverage car insurance may cost more than the state minimum, but it offers valuable protection beyond just covering damage to other drivers' vehicles. Unlike state minimum, full coverage includes damage to your vehicle in addition to liability coverage.
You can potentially lower your full coverage premiumThe payment required for an insurance policy to remain in force. Auto insurance premiums are quoted for either 6-month or annual policy periods. by comparing quotes from different carriers.
| Average 6 month premium | $1,391 |
| Average annual premium | $2,782 |
| State minimum premium | $608 |
Cheapest car insurance companies in Brookhaven
Travelers offers the cheapest rates on average at $1,605 per year. Nationwide is the second-most affordable auto insurance company on the list, based on our rate comparison for full coverage.
Car insurance prices differ based on where you live, your driving history, coverage limit and your insurance provider. To find the best deal on auto insurance, it's wise to compare quotes from various companies.
Below are the companies that offer cheap car insurance to drivers in Brookhaven.
| Company | Average 6 month premium | Average annual premium |
|---|---|---|
| Travelers | $803 | $1,605 |
| Nationwide | $1,026 | $2,052 |
| Erie Insurance | $1,042 | $2,083 |
| Westfield Insurance | $1,401 | $2,801 |
| GEICO | $1,470 | $2,940 |
| Allstate | $1,497 | $2,994 |
| State Farm | $1,692 | $3,383 |
| Donegal Insurance | $1,838 | $3,676 |
| Progressive | $2,075 | $4,149 |
| USAA | $1,067 | $2,134 |
Cheapest car insurance cost in Brookhaven by age group
Car insurance rates in Brookhaven vary by age group; the risk associated with insuring a driver differs by age, especially when it comes to younger, inexperienced drivers. Take a look at the cheapest companies in Brookhaven by age: as insurers consider factors like driving experience and accident risk while calculating the insurance premiums.
- Cheapest for teens: Travelers
- Cheapest for young adults: Travelers
- Cheapest for adults: Travelers
- Cheapest for seniors: Travelers
Teen drivers pay the highest insurance rates because they have the least driving experience and a higher likelihood of accidents. Travelers offers the cheapest car insurance for teens at $4,973 per year.
Travelers offers the most affordable auto insurance for young adults at $2,391 annually. Young adults typically see lower rates than teens but still pay more than older drivers. While they have more experience, statistics show they are more likely to engage in risky driving behaviors.
Adult drivers pay lowest car insurance premiums because they have more driving experience and a lower risk of accidents. Travelers provides the lowest car insurance rates at $1,608 per year for adult drivers in Brookhaven.
Travelers offers the least expensive car insurance for senior drivers in Brookhaven, at $1,581 per year. Insurance rates for senior drivers increase slightly due to factors like slower reaction times and higher accident risks.
| Company | Teens | Young adults | Adults | Seniors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Travelers | $4,973 | $2,391 | $1,608 | $1,581 |
| Erie Insurance | $5,308 | $3,307 | $2,078 | $2,086 |
| Nationwide | $9,429 | $3,726 | $2,080 | $1,951 |
| Westfield Insurance | $6,370 | $4,354 | $2,912 | $2,700 |
| GEICO | $6,764 | $4,097 | $2,976 | $2,788 |
| Allstate | $8,214 | $4,474 | $3,018 | $3,119 |
| State Farm | $10,586 | $5,866 | $3,389 | $3,292 |
| Donegal Insurance | $13,934 | $8,128 | $3,700 | $4,031 |
| Progressive | $12,272 | $7,356 | $4,088 | $3,937 |
| USAA | $8,103 | $3,230 | $2,153 | $2,166 |
Cheapest car insurance companies in Brookhaven by driver profile
Car insurance rates in Brookhaven vary by driver profile. Drivers with a history of accidents or tickets on their record will likely pay more for car insurance than those without any driving violations.
Below are some of the cheapest car insurance companies in Brookhaven by driver profile.
- Cheapest for poor credit: Nationwide
- Cheapest for an at-fault accident: Travelers
- Cheapest for a DUI: Travelers
- Cheapest for a driver with a speeding ticket: Travelers
Cheapest for a driver with poor credit: Nationwide
Nationwide is the most affordable car insurance for drivers with poor credit. On average, drivers in Brookhaven pay about $2,803 per year for it.
Here are some car insurance companies that offer cheap car insurance rates for drivers with poor credit in Brookhaven.
| Company | Average 6 month premium | Average annual premium |
|---|---|---|
| Nationwide | $1,402 | $2,803 |
| Travelers | $2,250 | $4,500 |
| Allstate | $2,474 | $4,947 |
| Erie Insurance | $2,488 | $4,976 |
| GEICO | $2,733 | $5,467 |
| Progressive | $3,628 | $7,255 |
| State Farm | $7,160 | $14,319 |
Cheapest auto insurance after an at-fault accident: Travelers
In Brookhaven, Travelers offers the cheapest car insurance for drivers with at-fault accident at $2,093 annually. An at-fault accident increases car insurance rates because it indicates that you are a higher risk for another accident. But some companies offer lower prices than others.
The table below shows the most affordable car insurance companies for drivers with an at-fault accident in Brookhaven.
| company | Average 6 month premium | Average annual premium |
|---|---|---|
| Travelers | $1,047 | $2,093 |
| Erie Insurance | $1,359 | $2,718 |
| Nationwide | $1,681 | $3,363 |
| State Farm | $1,919 | $3,838 |
| Allstate | $2,139 | $4,278 |
| GEICO | $2,379 | $4,758 |
| Progressive | $3,216 | $6,431 |
| USAA | $1,587 | $3,175 |
Cheapest auto insurance after a DUI: Travelers
Travelers offers the cheapest car insurance rates for drivers with a first offense DUI/DWI on their driving record. The average rate is $2,265 per year, making it the cheapest option amongst all the companies analyzed.
A DUI significantly increases your auto insurance premiums. But rates can be reduced over time by maintaining a clean driving record or completing a state-approved defensive driving course.
Here are the cheapest car insurance companies for drivers with a DUI in Brookhaven.
| Company | Average 6 month premium | Average annual premium |
|---|---|---|
| Travelers | $1,133 | $2,265 |
| Erie Insurance | $1,727 | $3,455 |
| State Farm | $1,815 | $3,630 |
| GEICO | $2,476 | $4,951 |
| Progressive | $2,507 | $5,014 |
| Nationwide | $2,582 | $5,165 |
| USAA | $1,438 | $2,877 |
Cheapest for drivers with a speeding ticket: Travelers
Travelers offers the cheapest car insurance at $1,945 in Brookhaven for drivers with speeding ticket on their driving records. Getting a speeding ticket can raise your car insurance rates, but some companies offer lower premiums than others.
Here are the companies offering cheap auto insurance for drivers with speeding ticket.
| Company | Average 6 month premium | Average annual premium |
|---|---|---|
| Travelers | $973 | $1,945 |
| Erie Insurance | $1,173 | $2,346 |
| State Farm | $1,815 | $3,630 |
| Nationwide | $1,853 | $3,707 |
| GEICO | $2,266 | $4,531 |
| USAA | $1,195 | $2,390 |
Car insurance discounts for Brookhaven drivers
The biggest car insurance discount available in Brookhaven is for the Student Away At School category at 35%, offered by State Farm.
Car insurance is essential for drivers in Brookhaven, but you should not pay more than necessary. Insurance companies offer a variety of discounts that can help lower your premium. Whether you're a safe driver, a student or bundle your home and auto insurance, there are savings opportunities available.
Here are some of the car insurance discounts insurers offer to Brookhaven drivers and how much you could save on average.
| Category | Company | Premium before discount | Premium after discount | % Discount | $ Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Air Bags | Travelers | $1,423 | $1,330 | 7% | $93 |
| Air Bags | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,831 | 1% | $17 |
| Air Bags | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,396 | 5% | $137 |
| Air Bags | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,617 | 2% | $43 |
| Air Bags | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,679 | 1% | $35 |
| Air Bags | GEICO | $2,974 | $2,877 | 3% | $97 |
| Air Bags | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,512 | 2% | $88 |
| Anti-Theft Device | Travelers | $1,423 | $1,379 | 3% | $44 |
| Anti-Theft Device | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,825 | 1% | $23 |
| Anti-Theft Device | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,470 | 2% | $62 |
| Anti-Theft Device | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,615 | 2% | $45 |
| Anti-Theft Device | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,647 | 2% | $67 |
| Anti-Theft Device | State Farm | $2,795 | $2,760 | 1% | $35 |
| Anti-Theft Device | GEICO | $2,974 | $2,947 | 1% | $27 |
| Anti-Theft Device | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,530 | 2% | $70 |
| Comp and Coll Deductibles | Travelers | $1,423 | $1,271 | 11% | $152 |
| Comp and Coll Deductibles | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,471 | 20% | $377 |
| Comp and Coll Deductibles | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,206 | 13% | $327 |
| Comp and Coll Deductibles | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,222 | 18% | $493 |
| Comp and Coll Deductibles | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,405 | 10% | $255 |
| Comp and Coll Deductibles | State Farm | $2,795 | $2,576 | 8% | $219 |
| Comp and Coll Deductibles | GEICO | $2,974 | $2,748 | 8% | $226 |
| Comp and Coll Deductibles | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,248 | 10% | $351 |
| Daily Commute | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,721 | 7% | $128 |
| Daily Commute | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,500 | 6% | $160 |
| Daily Commute | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,570 | 5% | $145 |
| Days Advanced Purchase | Travelers | $1,423 | $1,222 | 14% | $201 |
| Days Advanced Purchase | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,701 | 8% | $147 |
| Days Advanced Purchase | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,124 | 16% | $409 |
| Days Advanced Purchase | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,446 | 8% | $213 |
| Days Advanced Purchase | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,456 | 10% | $259 |
| Days Advanced Purchase | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,472 | 4% | $128 |
| Days Per Week Driven | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,633 | 3% | $82 |
| Education | GEICO | $2,974 | $2,834 | 5% | $139 |
| Education | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,261 | 9% | $339 |
| Electronic Funds Transfer | Travelers | $1,423 | $1,394 | 2% | $29 |
| Electronic Funds Transfer | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,431 | 4% | $102 |
| Electronic Signature | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,315 | 8% | $285 |
| Homeowner | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,424 | 4% | $109 |
| Homeowner | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,524 | 2% | $76 |
| Lower Annual Mileage | Travelers | $1,423 | $1,335 | 6% | $89 |
| Lower Annual Mileage | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,737 | 6% | $111 |
| Lower Annual Mileage | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,258 | 11% | $275 |
| Lower Annual Mileage | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,446 | 10% | $269 |
| Lower Annual Mileage | State Farm | $2,795 | $2,527 | 10% | $268 |
| Lower Annual Mileage | GEICO | $2,974 | $2,792 | 6% | $182 |
| Loyalty - Years Renewal With Company | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,761 | 5% | $87 |
| Loyalty - Years Renewal With Company | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,288 | 10% | $245 |
| Loyalty - Years Renewal With Company | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,449 | 10% | $266 |
| Loyalty - Years Renewal With Company | State Farm | $2,795 | $2,455 | 12% | $340 |
| Loyalty - Years Renewal With Company | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,578 | 3% | $81 |
| Loyalty - Years Renewal With Company | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,558 | 1% | $41 |
| Marital Status | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,735 | 6% | $113 |
| Marital Status | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,215 | 18% | $500 |
| Marital Status | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,395 | 5% | $138 |
| Marital Status | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,615 | 2% | $45 |
| Marital Status | GEICO | $2,974 | $2,924 | 2% | $50 |
| Marital Status | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,151 | 12% | $448 |
| Multi Policy | Travelers | $1,423 | $1,320 | 7% | $103 |
| Multi Policy | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,685 | 9% | $163 |
| Multi Policy | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,287 | 10% | $246 |
| Multi Policy | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,404 | 10% | $256 |
| Multi Policy | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,445 | 10% | $269 |
| Multi Policy | State Farm | $2,795 | $2,517 | 10% | $278 |
| Multi Policy | GEICO | $2,974 | $2,702 | 9% | $272 |
| Multi Policy | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,359 | 7% | $241 |
| Paperless/Electornic Documents | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,328 | 8% | $205 |
| Paperless/Electornic Documents | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,565 | 1% | $34 |
| Payment Type | Travelers | $1,423 | $1,352 | 5% | $71 |
| Payment Type | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,681 | 9% | $167 |
| Payment Type | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,316 | 9% | $217 |
| Payment Type | GEICO | $2,974 | $2,380 | 20% | $594 |
| Payment Type | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,531 | 5% | $128 |
| Payment Type | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,584 | 5% | $131 |
| Primary Use | Travelers | $1,423 | $1,352 | 5% | $71 |
| Primary Use | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,542 | 17% | $306 |
| Primary Use | State Farm | $2,795 | $2,246 | 20% | $549 |
| Primary Use | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,278 | 16% | $437 |
| Primary Use | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,417 | 5% | $116 |
| Primary Use | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,436 | 8% | $224 |
| Profession | GEICO | $2,974 | $2,834 | 5% | $139 |
| Profession | Progressive | $3,600 | $2,847 | 21% | $752 |
| Safety Devices | Erie Insurance | $1,848 | $1,838 | 1% | $10 |
| Safety Devices | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,515 | 1% | $17 |
| Safety Devices | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,628 | 1% | $31 |
| Safety Devices | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,656 | 2% | $59 |
| Telematics | Travelers | $1,423 | $1,281 | 10% | $142 |
| Telematics | Allstate | $2,533 | $2,226 | 12% | $307 |
| Telematics | State Farm | $2,795 | $2,682 | 4% | $112 |
| Telematics | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,242 | 10% | $358 |
| Years Insured | Travelers | $1,423 | $1,243 | 13% | $180 |
| Years Insured | Allstate | $2,533 | $1,919 | 24% | $614 |
| Years Insured | Donegal Insurance | $2,715 | $2,452 | 10% | $263 |
| Years Insured | Westfield Insurance | $2,660 | $2,531 | 5% | $128 |
| Years Insured | Progressive | $3,600 | $3,075 | 15% | $524 |
| Air Bags | USAA | $1,958 | $1,915 | 2% | $43 |
| Anti-Theft Device | USAA | $1,958 | $1,918 | 2% | $40 |
| Days Advanced Purchase | USAA | $1,958 | $1,855 | 5% | $103 |
| Electronic Funds Transfer | USAA | $1,958 | $1,902 | 3% | $56 |
| Lower Annual Mileage | USAA | $1,958 | $1,859 | 5% | $99 |
| Loyalty - Years Renewal With Company | USAA | $1,958 | $1,785 | 9% | $173 |
| Marital Status | USAA | $1,958 | $1,732 | 12% | $226 |
| Multi Policy | USAA | $1,958 | $1,821 | 7% | $137 |
| Primary Use | USAA | $1,958 | $1,878 | 4% | $80 |
| Safety Devices | USAA | $1,958 | $1,930 | 1% | $28 |
| Years Insured | USAA | $1,958 | $1,598 | 18% | $360 |
How to get cheap car insurance in Brookhaven in 2025
Find affordable car insurance in Brookhaven by following these smart strategies:
- Compare quotes from multiple insurers. Different insurance companies offer different rates, so it's important to shop around. Get quotes from at least three providers and compare coverage rates to find the best deal.
- Take advantage of discounts offered. Look for discounts for safe drivers, good students, bundling multiple policies (such as auto and home insurance), installing safety or anti-theft devices in your car or paying your premium in full instead of monthly.
- Choose a higher deductible. A higher deductible means you'll pay more out of pocket in case of a claim, but it also lowers your monthly premium. Make sure you can afford the one you picked.
- Maintain a good driving record. Safe driving can help you qualify for lower rates. Avoid speeding tickets, accidents and other violations to keep your insurance costs down.
- Drive a car that's cheaper to insure. Some cars cost more to insure than others. Vehicles with high safety ratings and lower repair costs usually have lower insurance premiums.
- Consider state minimum coverage (if appropriate). If you have an older car that isn't worth much, you might save money by choosing a basic liability policy instead of full coverage. However, make sure you meet the legal requirements in Brookhaven.
Methodology
Insurance.com commissioned 2023 data for the cheapest car insurance rates in cities from Quadrant Data Services for all 50 states and Washington, D.C. Rates are based on the following profile:
- 40-year-old male driver
- Honda Accord LX
- 12-mile daily commute, 10,000 annual miles
- Good credit
- Clean record
While the rates for drivers with poor credit, speeding tickets, DUI and at-fault accidents were sourced from the Auto Problems Report 2023.
Rates are based on coverage limits of:
- $100,000 bodily injury per person
- $300,000 bodily injury per accident
- $100,000 property damage per accident
- $500 comprehensive and collision deductible
Insurance.com analyzed rates from over 34,000 ZIP codes, 56 million quotes, and 136 companies. Based on the analysis, we have created lists of the cheapest companies for different driver profiles. USAA also made it to the list, but it offers services only to current and former military members and their families. Rates sourced from Quadrant Data Services for comparison purposes only; your rates may differ.
