Best cheap homeowners insurance companies
Below, you’ll see our choices for the best home insurance companies that offer affordable pricing and exceptional service. We looked at premiums, and all companies have below-average rates, but also coverage options, records of consumer complaints, claims satisfaction scores from J.D. Power, financial strength ratings and market share.
Company | J.D. Power (out of 1,000) | NAIC complaint ratio* | AM Best rating | Average annual rate |
---|---|---|---|---|
State Farm | 829 | 1.07 | A++ | $2,534 |
Auto-Owners | 825 | 0.19 | A++ | $2,355 |
Travelers | 794 | 0.60 | A++ | $2,109 |
Allstate | 815 | 2.04 | A+ | $2,383 |
Cheapest homeowners insurance companies
Wondering how to find cheap homeowners insurance? Shop around.
Insurance.com looked at average rates from dozens of insurance companies based on $300,000 in dwelling coverage and liability with a $1,000 deductible. Here are the rates from cheapest to most expensive. Not all companies are available in all areas.
Company Name | Average annual rate |
---|---|
Tokio Marine Holdings | $514 |
New Jersey Manufacturers | $747 |
Vermont Mutual | $766 |
Farm Bureau Mutual of Idaho | $783 |
West Bend Mutual | $884 |
Concord | $884 |
Andover Group | $1,005 |
Pemco | $1,005 |
New York Central Mutual | $1,045 |
CSAA Insurance Exchange | $1,113 |
Western National | $1,260 |
Auto Club | $1,319 |
North Carolina Farm Bureau | $1,337 |
Co Operative Insurance | $1,405 |
Arbella | $1,411 |
Palisades | $1,432 |
Quincy Mutual | $1,530 |
Cincinnati Insurance | $1,540 |
Acuity | $1,545 |
ARX Holding Corp | $1,577 |
MMG Insurance | $1,590 |
NBIC | $1,633 |
Amica | $1,638 |
IMT Insurance | $1,700 |
Safety | $1,709 |
Chubb | $1,737 |
Erie | $1,832 |
Michigan Farm Bureau | $1,973 |
Travelers | $2,019 |
COUNTRY Financial | $2,037 |
Westfield Insurance | $2,110 |
Mapfre Insurance | $2,112 |
Nationwide | $2,135 |
Nodak Mutual | $2,146 |
United Insurance | $2,207 |
USAA | $2,235 |
Liberty Mutual | $2,329 |
Auto-Owners | $2,355 |
Allstate | $2,383 |
Automobile Club MI | $2,521 |
Farmers | $2,534 |
State Farm | $2,534 |
Southern Farm Bureau | $2,539 |
Georgia Farm Bureau | $2,615 |
American Family | $2,654 |
South Carolina Farm Bureau | $2,811 |
Hanover | $2,830 |
Farm Bureau Mutual of AR | $3,122 |
Iowa Farm Bureau | $3,165 |
Louisiana Farm Bureau | $3,203 |
Shelter Insurance | $3,402 |
Alfa Mutual | $3,723 |
Indiana Farm Bureau | $3,725 |
Heritage Insurance | $3,978 |
Universal Insurance | $4,168 |
Kentucky Farm Bureau | $4,513 |
Citizens | $4,607 |
Cheapest home insurance companies by state
Find the cheapest home insurance company in your state in the table below.
State | Company Name | Company average annual premium | State average annual premium |
---|---|---|---|
Alabama | Allstate | $2,437 | $3,066 |
Alaska | COUNTRY Financial | $1,343 | $1,799 |
Arizona | American Family | $1,431 | $1,966 |
Arkansas | Shelter Insurance | $2,701 | $4,037 |
California | Allstate | $849 | $1,380 |
Colorado | State Farm | $3,006 | $3,388 |
Connecticut | Amica | $1,232 | $2,100 |
Delaware | Cumberland | $905 | $1,389 |
Florida | Security First | $887 | $4,218 |
Georgia | Farmers Ins Exch | $1,735 | $3,770 |
Hawaii | Allstate Ins Co | $384 | $597 |
Iowa | West Bend | $1,188 | $2,402 |
Idaho | Nationwide | $1,237 | $1,892 |
Illinois | Allstate | $1,406 | $2,604 |
Indiana | Allstate | $1,184 | $2,721 |
Kansas | Shelter | $3,396 | $4,665 |
Kentucky | Cincinnati | $1,888 | $3,163 |
Louisiana | United Insurance | $1,347 | $3,481 |
Massachusetts | State Farm | $705 | $1,518 |
Maryland | State Farm | $1,185 | $1,630 |
Maine | Vermont Mutual | $688 | $1,407 |
Michigan | Automobile Club MI | $1,384 | $2,607 |
Minnesota | Auto-Owners | $1,568 | $2,327 |
Missouri | Auto Club Enterprises | $2,014 | $3,349 |
Mississippi | Allstate | $1,345 | $3,398 |
Montana | Chubb | $1,344 | $2,874 |
North Carolina | State Farm | $1,291 | $2,768 |
North Dakota | Agraria Mutual | $1,719 | $2,946 |
Nebraska | American Family | $3,286 | $4,624 |
New Hampshire | Amica | $791 | $1,144 |
New Jersey | New Jersey Manufacturers | $855 | $1,267 |
New Mexico | Travelers Home & Marine Ins Co | $1,898 | $3,086 |
Nevada | Nationwide | $1,167 | $1,457 |
New York | New York Central Mutual | $1,083 | $1,728 |
Ohio | Cincinnati Ins Co | $1,323 | $3,671 |
Oklahoma | Allstate | $3,590 | $4,945 |
Oregon | American Family | $1,049 | $1,503 |
Pennsylvania | Nationwide Mut Fire Ins Co | $1,307 | $3,151 |
Rhode Island | State Farm | $943 | $1,774 |
South Carolina | Allstate | $1,515 | $2,379 |
South Dakota | North Star Mutual | $2,194 | $3,529 |
Tennessee | United Serv Automobile Assn | $2,139 | $3,696 |
Tennessee | Tennessee Farmers Mut Ins Co | $2,354 | $3,696 |
Texas | Progressive | $2,972 | $4,142 |
Utah | Nationwide | $971 | $1,421 |
Virginia | American Family | $863 | $1,999 |
Vermont | Vermont Mutual | $712 | $1,175 |
Washington | PEMCO | $919 | $1,659 |
Wisconsin | West Bend | $928 | $1,508 |
West Virginia | Allstate | $1,678 | $1,801 |
Wyoming | Nationwide | $1,233 | $1,801 |
How to get cheap home insurance
There are a lot of ways to save on home insurance. Here are some of the best expert tips for getting cheaper home insurance.
Comparison shop
One of the best ways to save is to shop around and compare insurance companies against one another.
Each insurer has its own formula for setting rates. That means your profile as a homeowner is likely a better match with some companies than others. Find the right company, and you can save a bundle.
Raise your deductible
A higher deductible means lower premiums because you agree to take on more of the repair cost if you file a claim. You're also less likely to file smaller claims. But before you raise your deductible to save, ensure you can afford it if you need to pay it.
Upgrade your home
Insurance companies offer discounts when you upgrade things like your roof, reducing the likelihood of a weather damage claim. Where you live will dictate which upgrades bring the biggest discount; in Florida, for example, hurricane shutters are a good choice, while in California fire-resistant materials might save you more.
Try to avoid attractive nuisances
An attractive nuisance is anything that draws interest, especially to children, but can be dangerous. Common examples include pools and trampolines. Having one or more of these can cause your rates to rise.
Maintain good credit
Some people are surprised to learn that their credit score can impact their insurance rates. But in many states, this is true. So, try to keep your credit score high. Insurance.com research has found that nothing will increase your insurance rates more than having poor credit. On average, homeowners with bad credit pay more than twice as much for homeowners insurance than those with excellent credit.
Bundle your insurance policies
Many homeowners insurance companies will cut you a break on premiums if you carry your other policies – such as auto insurance – through them. Insurance.com research has found that policyholders who bundle home and auto insurance save an average of 18% on coverage. You’ll save 4% each for bundling home and life insurance, and for bundling home and umbrella coverage.
Don’t file small claims
The true purpose of homeowners insurance is to protect you in the event of major and very costly mishaps. It makes sense to file a claim if a tornado damages your home. But you might want to skip filing a claim if someone accidentally cracks your window with a golf ball.
Avoiding making small claims can save you cash. Going five years without a claim can save you an average of 5%, while 10 years claims-free will net you another 5% savings.
Home insurance FAQs
How do I get cheap homeowners insurance if I have bad credit?
As we said above, bad credit can push your homeowners insurance rates sky-high. The best way to reverse this impact is to improve your credit over time gradually. It won’t happen overnight, but your insurance rates should fall as your score rises.
What company has the cheapest home and auto insurance bundle?
State Farm has the biggest auto and home bundling discount, based on Insurance.com data, at 25% on average.