Is your car insurance going the way of the landline?

By Michele Lerner Posted : 01/10/2013

car safety tech trends impact insuranceCars that jiggle you awake or alert you when you drive out of your lane represent just the beginning of technological changes that will make car accidents less common and, eventually, change how car insurance is priced, bought and sold, say industry analysts.

A recent article in Insurance & Technology magazine, "The Reshaping of Auto Insurance" by Marik Brockman and Anand Rao of PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC), reviews several trends that they believe will significantly transform the way car insurance works.

These trends include:

1. Risk shifting: Advanced technologies such as telematics, vehicle-to-vehicle communication, lane detection systems and automatic braking will shift responsibility for accidents from driver error to mechanical malfunction. (See: "As economy sinks, pay-as-you-go insurance soars.")

"In turn, this would shift the key buyer from the end-consumer to the car manufacturer, and fundamentally change the entire value chain, from product definition to pricing, marketing, distribution, underwriting, service, and claims," says the report. In this scenario, carriers would sell policies either at the dealership, or perhaps try to increase market share by "co-marketing with the manufacturer and/or dealer," says the report. (See: "Cars to predict red-light runners soon?")

2. Risk sharing: Social networking creates new pools of drivers to share group discounts.

"There are new carriers that combine social networking with insurance by connecting customers to form insurance networks that promise significantly lower premiums. These carriers claim that their models allow insurers to access new customers virally, decrease process costs and reduce claim ratios," according to the report. While, on the one hand, this represents the potential for lower rates for more groups, it also could make insurance more affordable for some and therefore lead to more insured drivers say the authors.

3. Risk slicing: The growth of car sharing, which means more car insurance policies that will follow a pay-per-use model instead of 24/7 coverage.

The increase in car sharing suggests a future in which many premiums move from 24-hour asset coverage to a pay-per-use model, according to the authors. The North American car-sharing market could surpass 4.4 million members and $3 billion by 2016, the report says, citing Frost & Sullivan research published in March 2012. More low-frequency drivers likely equates to at least some reduction in individual premiums. (See: "Hello, stranger! Here's my car keys.")

"However, this scenario does not necessarily represent only lost premiums," says the report. "Most of the people who do not choose to own cars will need to rent them at least occasionally; accordingly, car sharing can expand the market for alternative buyers of insurance."

4. Risk reduction: Driverless cars, which will require an entirely new model of insurance coverage based on the vehicle rather than the driver.

"Unlike the above scenarios that represent significant change but not necessarily extreme disruption to the insurance industry, driverless cars equipped with the latest awareness technologies could completely change the industry as we know it," says the report. Google's driverless vehicles have logged over 300,000 miles without an accident. Driverless cars are now legal on California roadways, and Google's U.S. spending on advocacy of driverless vehicles exceeded $9 million in just the first half of 2012, according to the report. (See: "Nevada bets on driverless cars, California's dreamin' of them")

Changes coming for auto insurance model…eventually

Based on these technological changes, Brockman, a partner with PwC, says he anticipates that many of the larger companies that provide auto insurance now will develop innovative insurance products that will be similar to product liability coverage.

"Some of the larger insurance companies already have a commercial insurance business, so we expect them to find creative ways to offer auto insurance for different types of vehicles, drivers and devices," says Brockman.

Insurance technology analyst Donald Light said in a blog post on the report: "If and when liability for many accidents shifts to the manufacturers of the automobiles (and/or the on-board equipment); it is likely that the frequency of accidents will be significantly lower, leading to lower losses, and lower premiums for auto insurers. So change is coming for auto insurers in terms of business and operating models. The big question is how quickly."

Robert Hunter, director of insurance for the Consumer Federation of America, thinks eventually individuals will not actually buy car insurance at all. Instead, a limited policy to pay for medical bills will come with a car purchase or lease. If an accident occurs, the insurance companies of the individual vendors will have to determine which feature failed and will be responsible for repairs or replacing the vehicle.

"It will take a long time, but I think 20 years from now car insurance will look totally different than it looks today," says Hunter. "Once driverless cars come into use there will naturally be less car accidents because the car won't get drunk or speed or get distracted by a pretty girl walking by. At that point, accidents will be caused by a manufacturing or installation error rather than driver error."

Why are so many discounts for outdated safety technology?

In the meantime, many vehicles already have safety features such as automatic brakes that stop your car from hitting another, rear-view cameras that prevent collisions when drivers are backing up and systems that alert you when you swerve into the wrong lane. You may pay a lower rate if you drive a car equipped with such high-tech systems. Yet not all insurance companies offer discounts for these features, though they typically do for more outdated items such as airbags and anti-lock brakes.

"Insurance companies are always a little bit behind," says Hunter. "There's a bit of a herd instinct there, so most of the car insurance companies will wait for one of the big ones like State Farm to offer a discount for a particular feature before they'll do it. At the same time, these companies legitimately want to gather data and make sure this stuff really works before they start promoting them and offering discounts on them."

Brockman says that some of the more advanced insurance carriers will monitor tests on auto safety features in advance and will offer their customers discounts earlier than others. (See: "Will insurers soon pay us not to speed?")

"Discounts for specific features follow a timeline that correlates with the release of a new product, followed by increasing customer adoption and increasing promotion of the product," says Brockman. "There's just a little lag time before discounts become available for new features."

Compare real rates and save real money
Valid Zipcode Required
Select
Invalid Age
Select
Invalid Carrier
Yes
No
Yes
No

Related Articles on Insurance.com

2 Responses to "Is your car insurance going the way of the landline?"
  1. Dennis H 28, Jan, 2013

    This is an interesting concept. Imagine not having to drive, and other than the vehicle malfunctions, no accidents. People that are afraid to drive but do because it is a necessity, people with poor eye sight, physical disabilities, etc are now being driven around to their destinations safe and sound. No speeding, no road rage, but with everyone also being in a hurry there certainly be a lot of people late because of poor planning. Love the idea and looking forward to purchasing one of these vehicles. Might even sit in the back seat and just relax.

      Reply»  
  2. CAV Insurance 16, Jan, 2013

    We are still pretty far away from most of these features appearing on every car. However, it is a good point that the insurance companies should be thinking ahead and deciding how they are going to charge depending on what kind of vehicle is being driven and what the features of that vehicle are.

      Reply»  

What do you think? You can add a helpful comment to this page by filling out the form below.
Just looking for a quote? Click here
 
 
 

FREE RATE QUOTES

On average, our customers

save $540

a year on car insurance.

See how much
we can help YOU save:

Get free quotes now:

Are you currently insured? Yes No
See The Most Popular Policies
Give your feedback