Will an insurer pay a claim even after you switch?

Which insurance company is responsible for paying a claim after you switch?

The insurance company you had an active policy with at the time of the incident is responsible for paying the claim, even if you switched carriers. You can file a claim with the previous company after switching, or continue an open claim after canceling your coverage. Your new insurance company isn't responsible for any losses that happened before your policy went into force. However, if you had a gap in coverage in between carriers, neither carrier has to pay for any damage during that time. If there was an overlap in coverage, the insurers will coordinate to determine coverage; you can't get two full payouts.

When the incident happened	Which carrier pays
Policy with the previous carrier was in force	Previous carrier
Policy with the new carrier was in force	New carrier
The previous policy was canceled, new policy had not yet begun	Neither (no coverage)
Policies overlapped, both were in force	One policy is primary, the other secondary

Can you file a claim with your new insurance company?

You can file a claim with your new insurance company if that policy was in force at the time of the incident. If you had a coverage overlap, the two carriers would follow a process called coordination of benefits; one carrier would be primary and the other secondary, in accordance with the terms of each policy. You can't receive two full payouts for the same claim; that's insurance fraud.

Does it matter if you wait to file a claim?

No, as long as you file the claim within the statute of limitations in your state (usually two years) and any timeframe laid out by the terms of the policy, waiting to file a claim doesn't affect the coverage. However, it's always best to file a claim as soon as possible, when the incident is still fresh and can be properly investigated.

FAQ: Filing a claim after switching companies

Can I switch car insurance after an accident?

Yes, you can switch car insurance companies after an accident. Switching insurers won't cancel the current claim, which will continue to be processed by the original insurer. Even if the claim is still pending, tell your new insurance company about the accident, so that it can provide accurate rates based on your history.

Can I switch car insurance with an open claim?

Yes, you can switch car insurance companies even if you have an open claim. The original insurer will still process the claim until it's resolved. When switching, you'll need to provide the new insurer with information about the open claim. It's essential to understand the potential implications of switching mid-claim, including how it may affect your coverage or the claim process. Consulting with both insurers can clarify any concerns before making the switch.

Helpful auto insurance tools and calculators