Which cities have the best drivers in 2026?

The cities with the best drivers in 2026

Brownsville, Texas, ranked No. 1 among 200 U.S. cities in Allstate’s 2026 America’s Best Drivers Report, with collision likelihood 27.5% below the national average. Boston, Massachusetts, ranked last, with a collision likelihood 188.7% above the national average.

Here are the 200 cities as ranked by Allstate in its 2026 report.

2026 rank	City	Average years between collisions	Collision likelihood relative to national average	2025 rank	Change: 2025 to 2026
1	Brownsville, TX	14.99	-27.50%	1	0
2	Fort Collins, CO	14.96	-27.40%	3	1
3	Boise, ID	14.07	-22.80%	2	-1
4	Laredo, TX	13.82	-21.40%	5	1
5	Cary, NC	12.82	-15.20%	4	-1
6	Madison, WI	12.81	-15.20%	9	3
7	McAllen, TX	12.76	-14.90%	11	4
8	Colorado Springs, CO	12.68	-14.40%	23	15
9	Eugene, OR	12.68	-14.30%	10	1
10	Olathe, KS	12.51	-13.10%	6	-4
11	Port St. Lucie, FL	12.5	-13.10%	8	-3
12	Overland Park, KS	12.45	-12.70%	15	3
13	Scottsdale, AZ	12.37	-12.20%	7	-6
14	Cape Coral, FL	12.35	-12.00%	14	0
15	Kansas City, KS	12.29	-11.60%	44	29
16	Chattanooga, TN	12.21	-11.00%	19	3
17	Huntsville, AL	12.14	-10.50%	12	-5
18	Gainesville, FL	11.88	-8.50%	16	-2
19	Gilbert, AZ	11.85	-8.30%	21	2
20	Orlando, FL	11.72	-7.30%	27	7
21	Tallahassee, FL	11.59	-6.30%	37	16
22	Amarillo, TX	11.59	-6.30%	28	6
23	Knoxville, TN	11.58	-6.20%	17	-6
24	Fayetteville, NC	11.52	-5.70%	13	-11
25	Lexington, KY	11.48	-5.40%	24	-1
26	St. Petersburg, FL	11.4	-4.70%	25	-1
27	Lakewood, CO	11.39	-4.60%	22	-5
28	Corpus Christi, TX	11.37	-4.50%	20	-8
29	Chandler, AZ	11.36	-4.40%	26	-3
30	Chesapeake, VA	11.33	-4.10%	33	3
31	Jacksonville, FL	11.29	-3.80%	31	0
32	Thornton, CO	11.25	-3.40%	30	-2
33	Lubbock, TX	11.17	-2.70%	45	12
34	Roseville, CA	11.16	-2.60%	18	-16
35	Winston-Salem, NC	11.11	-2.20%	43	8
36	Columbus, GA	11.09	-2.00%	58	22
37	Wichita, KS	11.07	-1.90%	56	19
38	Pembroke Pines, FL	10.94	-0.70%	52	14
39	Visalia, CA	10.89	-0.20%	76	37
40	Fort Lauderdale, FL	10.88	-0.20%	47	7
41	Birmingham, AL	10.81	0.50%	55	14
42	Durham, NC	10.79	0.70%	40	-2
43	Naperville, IL	10.76	1.00%	39	-4
44	Lincoln, NE	10.72	1.40%	42	-2
45	El Paso, TX	10.7	1.60%	38	-7
46	Greensboro, NC	10.65	2.00%	34	-12
47	Virginia Beach, VA	10.65	2.00%	46	-1
48	Mesa, AZ	10.63	2.20%	35	-13
49	Bellevue, WA	10.62	2.30%	41	-8
50	Anchorage, AK	10.61	2.40%	32	-18
51	Tulsa, OK	10.61	2.40%	70	19
52	Clarksville, TN	10.6	2.40%	62	10
53	Mobile, AL	10.58	2.70%	65	12
54	Springfield, MO	10.42	4.30%	48	-6
55	Aurora, IL	10.41	4.40%	66	11
56	Miami, FL	10.4	4.50%	72	16
57	Spokane, WA	10.39	4.50%	73	16
58	Akron, OH	10.39	4.60%	57	-1
59	Peoria, AZ	10.37	4.80%	50	-9
60	Shreveport, LA	10.35	4.90%	49	-11
61	Montgomery, AL	10.32	5.30%	61	0
62	Fort Wayne, IN	10.3	5.50%	53	-9
63	Salem, OR	10.28	5.70%	54	-9
64	Oklahoma City, OK	10.19	6.60%	63	-1
65	Macon, GA	10.16	6.90%	89	24
66	Reno, NV	10.13	7.20%	64	-2
67	Vancouver, WA	10.13	7.30%	51	-16
68	Raleigh, NC	10.12	7.30%	60	-8
69	Toledo, OH	10.08	7.70%	69	0
70	Rockford, IL	10.05	8.10%	36	-34
71	Surprise, AZ	10.04	8.20%	67	-4
72	Waco, TX	10.02	8.50%	112	40
73	Hollywood, FL	10	8.70%	82	9
74	Milwaukee, WI	9.89	9.80%	59	-15
75	Charleston, SC	9.89	9.90%	93	18
76	Salinas, CA	9.87	10.10%	106	30
77	Chula Vista, CA	9.77	11.20%	83	6
78	Bakersfield, CA	9.76	11.30%	90	12
79	Tucson, AZ	9.75	11.40%	71	-8
80	Killeen, TX	9.73	11.60%	74	-6
81	Pasadena, TX	9.73	11.70%	89	-2
82	Hialeah, FL	9.7	11.90%	87	5
83	Murfreesboro, TN	9.69	12.10%	80	-3
84	Albuquerque, NM	9.69	12.10%	86	2
85	Oceanside, CA	9.63	12.80%	104	19
86	Louisville, KY	9.62	13.00%	84	-2
87	Tampa, FL	9.59	13.20%	68	-19
88	Joliet, IL	9.58	13.40%	78	-10
89	Huntington Beach, CA	9.57	13.50%	103	14
90	Honolulu, HI	9.57	13.60%	75	-15
91	Little Rock, AR	9.56	13.70%	77	-14
92	Jersey City, NJ	9.48	14.50%	98	6
93	Salt Lake City, UT	9.46	14.80%	94	1
94	Memphis, TN	9.43	15.10%	88	-6
95	Newport News, VA	9.42	15.30%	97	2
96	Metairie, LA	9.4	15.50%	#N/A	New addition
97	Augusta, GA	9.4	15.60%	85	-12
98	Oxnard, CA	9.37	15.90%	91	-7
99	Rancho Cucamonga, CA	9.34	16.30%	109	10
100	Des Moines, IA	9.27	17.20%	108	8
101	Denver, CO	9.26	17.30%	127	26
102	Seattle, WA	9.23	17.70%	100	-2
103	Charlotte, NC	9.23	17.70%	99	-4
104	Elk Grove, CA	9.19	18.20%	81	-23
105	Corona, CA	9.17	18.40%	121	16
106	Denton, TX	9.13	19.00%	123	17
107	Portland, OR	9.11	19.30%	102	-5
108	Kansas City, MO	9.1	19.40%	101	-7
109	Tempe, AZ	9.09	19.50%	119	10
110	Nashville, TN	9.09	19.50%	107	-3
111	Fremont, CA	9.08	19.70%	116	5
112	Omaha, NE	9.03	20.30%	96	-16
113	Henderson, NV	9.03	20.30%	92	-21
114	Sunnyvale, CA	9.02	20.50%	114	0
115	San Diego, CA	8.99	20.80%	117	2
116	McKinney, TX	8.94	21.50%	118	2
117	Tacoma, WA	8.89	22.20%	110	-7
118	Santa Rosa, CA	8.88	22.30%	111	-7
119	Santa Clarita, CA	8.85	22.70%	137	18
120	Fontana, CA	8.83	23.10%	133	13
121	Grand Prairie, TX	8.79	23.60%	113	-8
122	Phoenix, AZ	8.76	24.10%	115	-7
123	Lehigh Acres, FL	8.73	24.40%	#N/A	New addition
124	Riverside, CA	8.62	26.00%	132	8
125	Plano, TX	8.6	26.30%	122	-3
126	Cleveland, OH	8.56	26.80%	146	20
127	Fresno, CA	8.52	27.50%	136	9
128	Savannah, GA	8.52	27.50%	158	30
129	Aurora, CO	8.49	27.90%	130	1
130	Escondido, CA	8.46	28.40%	120	-10
131	Sioux Falls, SD	8.46	28.50%	125	-6
132	Frisco, TX	8.4	29.30%	95	-37
133	Modesto, CA	8.39	29.50%	150	17
134	San Antonio, TX	8.38	29.60%	129	-5
135	Austin, TX	8.37	29.80%	135	0
136	New York, NY	8.37	29.80%	140	4
137	Indianapolis, IN	8.33	30.50%	126	-11
138	Fort Worth, TX	8.31	30.70%	128	-10
139	New Orleans, LA	8.3	30.90%	168	29
140	Pomona, CA	8.29	31.00%	149	9
141	Cincinnati, OH	8.29	31.10%	157	16
142	Irving, TX	8.28	31.10%	134	-8
143	Moreno Valley, CA	8.25	31.70%	152	9
144	Arlington, TX	8.19	32.60%	143	-1
145	San Jose, CA	8.19	32.70%	144	-1
146	Minneapolis, MN	8.19	32.70%	160	14
147	Columbus, OH	8.14	33.50%	141	-6
148	Stockton, CA	8.12	33.70%	153	5
149	Lancaster, CA	8.11	33.90%	124	-25
150	Ontario, CA	8.1	34.10%	145	-5
151	Norfolk, VA	8.02	35.40%	139	-12
152	Rochester, NY	8	35.80%	148	-4
153	Glendale, AZ	7.96	36.40%	138	-15
154	Hayward, CA	7.96	36.50%	162	8
155	Houston, TX	7.93	37.00%	154	-1
156	Yonkers, NY	7.91	37.30%	163	7
157	St. Paul, MN	7.89	37.60%	172	15
158	St. Louis, MO	7.84	38.60%	175	17
159	Mesquite, TX	7.84	38.60%	151	-8
160	Baton Rouge, LA	7.79	39.50%	159	-1
161	Palmdale, CA	7.78	39.60%	131	-30
162	Irvine, CA	7.73	40.50%	169	7
163	San Bernardino, CA	7.7	41.00%	164	1
164	Richmond, VA	7.66	41.70%	161	-3
165	Dallas, TX	7.64	42.10%	165	0
166	Buffalo, NY	7.62	42.50%	155	-11
167	Arlington, VA	7.61	42.80%	147	-20
168	Syracuse, NY	7.6	43.00%	173	5
169	Chicago, IL	7.56	43.70%	156	-13
170	San Francisco, CA	7.5	44.90%	178	8
171	Paterson, NJ	7.44	46.00%	167	-4
172	Sacramento, CA	7.41	46.50%	177	5
173	Santa Ana, CA	7.37	47.50%	176	3
174	Enterprise, NV	7.35	47.80%	166	-8
175	Garland, TX	7.3	48.90%	170	-5
176	Anaheim, CA	7.29	48.90%	181	5
177	Pittsburgh, PA	7.29	49.00%	171	-6
178	Las Vegas, NV	7.24	50.00%	174	-4
179	Long Beach, CA	7.21	50.60%	183	4
180	Detroit, MI	7.19	51.10%	142	-38
181	Atlanta, GA	7.17	51.50%	189	8
182	Newark, NJ	7.03	54.50%	180	-2
183	Paradise, NV	6.98	55.50%	184	1
184	Spring Valley, NV	6.96	56.10%	179	-5
185	Garden Grove, CA	6.79	59.90%	182	-3
186	Bridgeport, CT	6.64	63.70%	186	0
187	North Las Vegas, NV	6.63	63.90%	185	-2
188	Grand Rapids, MI	6.62	64.10%	187	-1
189	Alexandria, VA	6.21	75.00%	188	-1
190	Oakland, CA	6.2	75.10%	193	3
191	Philadelphia, PA	6.12	77.60%	191	0
192	Los Angeles, CA	5.99	81.50%	194	2
193	Sunrise Manor, NV	5.95	82.60%	190	-3
194	Providence, RI	5.87	85.10%	192	-2
195	Glendale, CA	5.53	96.50%	195	0
196	Springfield, MA	5.18	109.60%	196	0
197	Worcester, MA	5.14	111.20%	197	0
198	Baltimore, MD	4.49	142.10%	198	0
199	Washington, DC	4.24	156.30%	199	0
200	Boston, MA	3.76	188.70%	200	0