Call our licensed agents toll free 844.855.0163
Go To Top

If you rent a home or apartment, then it is important that you have the right renters insurance to protect your personal property and its contents. Renters insurance covers damage caused by smoke or fire, vandalism, theft, a windstorm, and other disasters.

Renters insurance costs an average of $384 a year for Ohio residents. However, rates vary based on the zip code, property you want to insure, coverage you choose, among other factors.

If you are in search of the best renters insurance in Ohio, then this guide is for you. We have compared major insurance carriers and their average annual premiums for Ohio residents. Read on to know more about the insurance companies that have the best renters insurance policies, insurers that provide cheap renters insurance, and the least and most expensive zip codes for renters insurance in Ohio.

Best renters insurance companies in Ohio

When it comes to choosing the best renters insurance company in Ohio, you want to make sure that you are comparing apples to apples. Our experts at Insurance.com have compared quotes, coverage options and J.D Power score from all the major insurers in Ohio. Below is the list of best renters insurance companies in Ohio:

  • USAA
  • State Farm
  • American Family
  • Nationwide
  • Allstate

Compare best renters insurance companies in Ohio

USAA earned the highest J.D. Power score (893) among the insurance companies surveyed, its average insurance rate is $254 a year. However, USAA only offers insurance coverage to military members, veterans, and their family members. If you don't qualify for renters insurance coverage from USAA, you can consider buying a policy from State Farm. It has earned 866 scores out of 1000 from J.D Power.

You may want to take a look at what each plan offers, and which providers offer excellent customer service. The most important thing is to compare quotes from all the options available before making a final decision to get a standard renters insurance policy.

Find below the list of best renters insurance providers and their average annual insurance rates.

CompanyJ.D. Power scoreAverage annual rate
USAA893$254
State Farm866$299
American Family838$327
Nationwide834$441
Allstate833$346
Farmers831$568
Liberty Mutual823$1,272
Travelers815$385

How much is renters insurance in Ohio

The average annual premium for renters insurance in Ohio is $384 or $32 a month. However, this amount may vary by location and the amount of coverage you choose.

Based on an analysis by Insurance.com, the recommended coverage level for renters insurance is $40,000 for personal property coverage, with a $1,000 deductible and $100,000 of liability coverage.

Average annual premiumAverage monthly premium
$384$32

10 Most expensive zip codes in Ohio for renters insurance

If you are a renter in Ohio, it's important to know that your Ohio renters insurance premium may vary depending on the zip code you live in. The most expensive zip code for renters insurance in Ohio is 43604, its average rate is $458 annually.

Here are the 10 most expensive zip codes in Ohio for renters insurance-

ZIP codeAverage annual rate
43604$458
43611$455
43601$453
45402$452
43613$449
43609$448
43607$444
45417$443
45406$440
45439$439

10 Least expensive zip codes in Ohio for renters insurance

Insurance companies take into account several factors including your zip code when deciding premiums. The least expensive zip code for renters insurance in Ohio is 44130, its average annual rate is $338.

We have gathered price quotes from major insurance companies across all the zip codes that provide affordable renters insurance and prepared a list of the 10 least expensive zip codes in Ohio for renters insurance.

ZIP codeAverage annual rate
44130$338
44070$339
44017$340
44129$341
44125$342
44116$343
44141$344
44107$346
44049$347
44123$348

Cheap renters insurance in Ohio by carrier

One of the best ways to save money on renters insurance is to get quotes from several different companies to find out who offers the cheapest Ohio renters insurance. Among the carriers surveyed, Cincinnati Insurance is the cheapest renters insurance company in Ohio, its average annual premium is $132.

Find below the list of best cheap renters insurance companies in Ohio and their average annual premium.

Company nameAverage annual premium
Cincinnati Insurance$132
Allstate$215
USAA$223
Garrison$240
State Farm$289
American Family$322
Travelers$335
Nationwide$375
Safeco$422
Farmers$490
Farmers$574
Liberty$1,206