Best homeowners insurance company in Virginia: Virginia Farm Bureau

The best home insurance company in Virginia, according to our ratings, is Virginia Farm Bureau. Travelers, Erie Insurance, American Family and State Farm are among the other top home insurance companies in Virginia.

The total Insurance.com score is calculated on a scale of 5 using these factors: price, NAIC complaints, and A.M. Best financial ratings.

Graph
Table
CompanyAM BestAverage annual rateNAIC complaint ratioInsurance.com score
Virginia Farm BureauA$1,3730.184.65
TravelersA++$1,9800.914.43
Erie InsuranceA$2,5720.464.38
American FamilyA$1,0461.074.26
State FarmA+$1,5821.154.26
FarmersA$2,0850.894.22
AllstateA+$2,1311.264.14
NationwideA$1,9251.344.03
ProgressiveA+$2,7461.53.96

Cheapest home insurance company in Virginia: American Family

American Family has the most affordable rates in all coverage levels except for $600,000 and $1,000,000 dwelling coverage.

The table below shows home insurance rates for Virginia insurers for five different levels of dwelling coverage, each with $300,000 in liability and a $1,000 deductible.

Cheapest home insurance rates in Virginia by coverage level
Company$200,000$300,000$400,000$600,000$1,000,000
Allstate$1,818$2,131$2,487$3,321$5,068
American Family$770$1,046$1,514$3,001$5,825
Erie Insurance$1,990$2,572$3,392$4,644$7,661
Farmers$1,796$2,085$2,596$4,029$6,392
Nationwide$1,465$1,925$2,281$3,091$4,430
Progressive$2,280$2,746$3,218$3,941$5,316
State Farm$1,262$1,582$1,887$2,374$3,117
Travelers$1,728$1,980$2,361$3,204$4,960
Virginia Farm Bureau$1,023$1,373$1,677$2,490$3,782

How much is homeowners insurance in Virginia?

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Virginia is $1,939 a year or $162 a month. This is based on coverage of:

  • $300,000 dwelling
  • $300,000 liability
  • $1,000 deductible.
  • 2% Hurricane deductible

Rates vary based on a lot of factors, so you should compare quotes from several homeowners insurance companies to get the best deal. 

Virginia home insurance rates by ZIP code

Since home insurance rates can vary greatly depending on where your home is located, it’s important to compare rates by ZIP code to see how areas stack up.

Use the home insurance calculator below to see the average rates in an area. Enter your ZIP code and coverage level to compare high and low premiums from major home insurers and see how much you can save by shopping around.

Home insurance calculator by ZIP code

Average home insurance rates in Texas
Please enter valid zip code

Most & least expensive ZIP codes for homeowners insurance in Texas

ZIP codeCityHighest rate
77550Galveston$10,407
77554Galveston$9,754
77551Galveston$9,634
77590Texas City$9,005
ZIP codeCityLowest rate
79915El Paso$1,158
79905El Paso$1,169
79907El Paso$1,179
79916Fort Bliss$1,180

The Virginia State Corporation Commission says...

Ask your agent if he charges additional fees over and above his commission. Agents are allowed to charge fees for services, such as photocopying, mailing, and faxing, as long as the applicant or policyholder consents in writing before the services are performed. A schedule of fees must be kept in the agent's office. If you think your agent is charging too much, check with other agents to find out if they charge additional fees.

- The Virginia State Corporation Commission

What are the most expensive ZIP codes in Virginia for home insurance?

Virginia homeowners insurance rates are the most expensive for ZIP code 23459, with an average annual cost of $4,676.

The most expensive ZIP codes in Virginia are:

CityZIP codeAverage Annual Premium
Virginia Beach23459$4,676
Virginia Beach23461$4,336
Virginia Beach23451$4,277
Virginia Beach23457$3,922
Virginia Beach23454$3,794
Cape Charles23310$3,658
Tangier23440$3,619
Machipongo23405$3,550
New Point23125$3,474
Hampton23664$3,419

What are the least expensive ZIP codes in Virginia for home insurance?

The cheapest ZIP code in Virginia for home insurance is 20141, with an average annual cost of $1,427. The top five cheapest ZIP codes are:

CityZIP codeAverage Annual Premium
Round Hill20141$1,427
Arlington22207$1,428
Fairfax22035$1,430
Arlington22205$1,434
Alexandria22332$1,441
Arlington22201$1,444
Arlington22203$1,448
Arlington22213$1,450
Alexandria22301$1,457
Broadway22815$1,462

Virginia homeowners insurance rates by county

Arlington is the cheapest county in Virginia for homeowners insurance at an average of $122 a month. At $295 a month, Virginia Beach is the most expensive county.

Use the map below to compare average rates by county in Virginia to see which areas are cheaper.

Map
Table
Average annual premium
$1,466
$3,546
CountyAverage annual premiumAverage monthly premium
Accomack$2,706$225
Albemarle$1,581$132
Alexandria$1,577$131
Alleghany$1,608$134
Amelia$1,899$158
Amherst$1,682$140
Appomattox$1,791$149
Arlington$1,466$122
Augusta$1,616$135
Bath$1,631$136
Bedford$1,667$139
Bland$1,851$154
Botetourt$1,554$130
Bristol$1,627$136
Brunswick$2,139$178
Buchanan$1,949$162
Buckingham$1,861$155
Buena Vista$1,759$147
Campbell$1,758$146
Caroline$1,784$149
Carroll$1,807$151
Charles City$2,065$172
Charlotte$1,931$161
Charlottesville$1,545$129
Chesapeake$2,578$215
Chesterfield$1,937$161
Clarke$1,646$137
Colonial Heights$1,879$157
Covington$1,576$131
Craig$1,604$134
Culpeper$1,666$139
Cumberland$1,859$155
Danville$1,805$150
Dickenson$1,937$161
Dinwiddie$2,040$170
Emporia$2,178$181
Essex$1,915$160
Fairfax$1,579$132
Fairfax city$1,507$126
Falls Church$1,500$125
Fauquier$1,733$144
Floyd$1,720$143
Fluvanna$1,718$143
Franklin$1,725$144
Franklin city$2,352$196
Frederick$1,590$133
Fredericksburg$1,635$136
Galax$1,742$145
Giles$1,690$141
Gloucester$2,240$187
Goochland$1,835$153
Grayson$1,764$147
Greene$1,607$134
Greensville$2,186$182
Halifax$1,948$162
Hampton$2,839$237
Hanover$1,861$155
Harrisonburg$1,518$126
Henrico$1,857$155
Henry$1,799$150
Highland$1,586$132
Hopewell$1,950$163
Isle Of Wight$2,517$210
James City$2,050$171
King And Queen$1,969$164
King George$1,832$153
King William$1,959$163
Lancaster$2,104$175
Lee$1,904$159
Lexington$1,575$131
Loudoun$1,648$137
Louisa$1,801$150
Lunenburg$1,999$167
Lynchburg$1,636$136
Madison$1,692$141
Manassas$1,573$131
Manassas Park$1,563$130
Martinsville$1,777$148
Mathews$2,837$236
Mecklenburg$2,054$171
Middlesex$2,271$189
Montgomery$1,604$134
Nelson$1,702$142
New Kent$1,910$159
Newport News$2,313$193
Norfolk$2,718$226
Northampton$3,118$260
Northumberland$2,205$184
Norton$1,848$154
Nottoway$1,919$160
Orange$1,802$150
Page$1,563$130
Patrick$1,831$153
Petersburg$1,952$163
Pittsylvania$1,837$153
Poquoson$2,998$250
Portsmouth$2,542$212
Powhatan$1,713$143
Prince Edward$1,900$158
Prince George$1,963$164
Prince William$1,665$139
Pulaski$1,703$142
Radford$1,655$138
Rappahannock$1,716$143
Richmond$1,942$162
Richmond City$1,785$149
Roanoke$1,563$130
Roanoke City$1,534$128
Rockbridge$1,637$136
Rockingham$1,509$126
Russell$1,845$154
Salem$1,528$127
Scott$1,830$152
Shenandoah$1,575$131
Smyth$1,761$147
Southampton$2,326$194
Spotsylvania$1,745$145
Stafford$1,728$144
Staunton$1,562$130
Suffolk$2,706$225
Surry$2,316$193
Sussex$2,152$179
Tazewell$1,855$155
Virginia Beach$3,546$295
Warren$1,571$131
Washington$1,736$145
Waynesboro$1,569$131
Westmoreland$1,971$164
Williamsburg$2,083$174
Winchester$1,580$132
Wise$1,893$158
Wythe$1,751$146
York$2,340$195

Compare homeowners insurance rates by city in Virginia

The table below displays average rates across various cities. Home insurance rates are influenced by factors such as weather, crime, and property values. Virginia Beach has the highest premiums at $2,642, while Roanoke is the cheapest at $1,272.

CityAnnual insurance premium
Alexandria
$1,285
Chesapeake
$2,070
Hampton
$2,105
Newport News
$1,845
Norfolk
$2,115
Portsmouth
$1,986
Richmond
$1,500
Roanoke
$1,272
Suffolk
$2,068
Virginia Beach
$2,642

How much homeowners insurance do you need in Virginia?

Unlike car insurance, there is no law requiring you to have home insurance or specifying the minimum coverage you need. To get the right coverage for your home, you need to consider:

  • Replacement cost: How much would it cost to rebuild your home?
  • Other structures: Typically 10% of your dwelling coverage. You may need more if you have outbuildings
  • Personal property: Inventory your belongings to get an idea of how much coverage you need

To help you shop for coverage, here’s a look at the basic components of home insurance and how much to get to make sure you’re not underinsured.

Insurance.com worked with Quadrant Information Services to field homeowners insurance rates in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. We analyzed 37,973,840 insurance quotes from 134 insurance companies across 34,595 ZIP codes to determine the average premiums.

The insurance rates are based on a sample profile of a homeowner with good credit and the following coverage level:

  • $300,000 dwelling coverage
  • $300,000 liability protection
  • $1,000 deductible
  • 2% hurricane deductible where appropriate.

To rank insurance companies, we used three important factors: average annual cost, NAIC complaint ratio and AM Best financial stability rating. Find the full best insurance companies rating methodology here. The quoted insurance rates are for comparison purposes. Your rates will vary.

FAQ: Virginia home insurance

Is damage from wind and hail covered by home insurance in Virginia?

Wind and hail damage are typically covered by standard home insurance policies. However, some insurance companies may include a separate deductible for hurricane damage. Also, some home insurance policies do not cover cosmetic damage from hail.

No. You need to buy a separate flood insurance policy from a private company or through the federal National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP). There is typically a 30-day waiting period for a new flood insurance policy to take effect, so you can’t wait until a hurricane is about to hit and expect to buy a policy that will protect you immediately.

Follow insurance.com on Google