Go To Top

Mazda MX-5 is a popular car of the Mazda brand and it's no surprise that its insurance rates are just as competitive. The average cost for 2021 Mazda MX-5 is $1,544 per year for drivers age 30. You should always compare rates from multiple insurers to make sure you're getting the best deal possible. That's why we've gathered quotes from some of the top carriers in the industry. Compare car insurance rates now and see how much you could save on your policy.

Average insurance cost of Mazda MX-5 by model year
Graph
Table
Year of Mazda MX-5 ModelAverage Cost to Insure
2020$1,458
2019$1,555
2018$1,495
2017$1,508
2016$1,440

Compare Mazda MX-5 Insurance Rates by State

L O A D I N G
Company Style Full Coverage(Avg) Liability Coverage(Avg) State Minimum Coverage(Avg)
Allstate2 Door Convertible$2,060$680$585
Geico2 Door Convertible$1,435$458$323
Farmers2 Door Convertible$1,778$681$576
Nationwide2 Door Convertible$2,214$798$594
Progressive2 Door Convertible$1,790$470$329
State Farm2 Door Convertible$2,065$695$493

2020 Mazda MX-5 Insurance Rates

companiesAverage Premium
State Farm$1,133
Geico$1,159
Progressive$1,314
Nationwide$1,359
Farmers$1,514
Allstate$2,271
Average Cost to Insure $1,458/year
Cheapest Rate $1,133/year
Available Trims Miata Club, Miata Grand Touring, Miata RF Club, Miata RF Grand Touring, Miata Sport

2019 Mazda MX-5 Insurance Rates

companiesAverage Premium
Geico$1,126
State Farm$1,225
Nationwide$1,288
Progressive$1,683
Farmers$1,731
Allstate$2,276
Average Cost to Insure $1,555/year
Cheapest Rate $1,126/year
Available Trims Miata Club, Miata Grand Touring, Miata RF Club, Miata RF Grand Touring, Miata Sport

2018 Mazda MX-5 Insurance Rates

companiesAverage Premium
Geico$1,078
State Farm$1,203
Nationwide$1,301
Progressive$1,651
Farmers$1,688
Allstate$2,048
Average Cost to Insure $1,495/year
Cheapest Rate $1,078/year
Available Trims Miata Club, Miata Grand Touring, Miata RF Club, Miata RF Grand Touring, Miata Sport

2017 Mazda MX-5 Insurance Rates

companiesAverage Premium
Geico$1,057
State Farm$1,188
Nationwide$1,330
Progressive$1,629
Farmers$1,640
Allstate$2,201
Average Cost to Insure $1,508/year
Cheapest Rate $1,057/year
Available Trims Miata Club, Miata Grand Touring, Miata RF Club, Miata RF Grand Touring, Miata Sport

2016 Mazda MX-5 Insurance Rates

companiesAverage Premium
Geico$1,021
State Farm$1,138
Nationwide$1,239
Farmers$1,590
Progressive$1,604
Allstate$2,049
Average Cost to Insure $1,440/year
Cheapest Rate $1,021/year
Available Trims Miata Club, Miata Grand Touring, Miata RF Club, Miata RF Grand Touring, Miata Sport