Ashlee Tilford Written by Ashlee Tilford
Managing Editor

Ashlee is a dynamic business writer and editor with a focus on personal finance. With an MBA and more than fourteen years in the finance industry, Ashlee brings a practical and relatable perspective to insurance topics. She is passionate about empowering others to achieve financial success and protect their assets. When Ashlee isn't writing and editing, she enjoys spending time with her partner, dog and chickens on their farm in Kentucky.


Why trust us?

Car insurance rates vary based on the make and model of the vehicle and trim levels. According to Insurance.com research, the average cost of insuring a Toyota 86 is $1,954 per year or $163 per month. However, these rates can vary depending on your location, driving history, age, and other factors.

The auto insurance rates also change based on the vehicle’s model year. For example, the 2021 Toyota 86 costs $1,954 per year, whereas the 2020 Toyota 86 costs $2,121 annually. State Farm offers the cheapest annual rate for 2021 Toyota 86 $1,350 per year.

Keep reading to learn more about which state offers the cheapest car insurance rates based on model year and which model year is the cheapest to insure amongst all the models surveyed by Insurance.com.

Average insurance cost of Toyota 86 by model year

Year of Toyota 86 ModelAverage Cost to Insure
2021$1,954
2020$2,121
2019$2,140
2018$2,019
2017$1,988
Graph Icon

Compare Toyota 86 insurance rates by state

L O A D I N G
CompanyStyleAverage annual premium
Allstate2 Door Coupe$2,751
Farmers2 Door Coupe$2,623
Geico2 Door Coupe$1,807
Nationwide2 Door Coupe$3,882
Progressive2 Door Coupe$1,567
State Farm2 Door Coupe$2,473

Toyota 86 insurance rates per year

2021

2021 Toyota 86 insurance rates

Average cost to insure $1,954
Annual cheapest rate $1,350
Available trims GT, Hakone Edition
RankCompanyAverage annual premium
1State Farm$1,350
2Geico$1,403
3Progressive$1,404
4Nationwide$1,927
5Farmers$2,698
6Allstate$2,941
2020

2020 Toyota 86 insurance rates

Average cost to insure $2,121
Annual cheapest rate $1,423
Available trims GT, Hakone Edition
RankCompanyAverage annual premium
1Geico$1,423
2State Farm$1,529
3Progressive$1,800
4Nationwide$2,131
5Farmers$2,858
6Allstate$2,983
2019

2019 Toyota 86 insurance rates

Average cost to insure $2,140
Annual cheapest rate $1,337
Available trims GT, Hakone Edition
RankCompanyAverage annual premium
1Geico$1,337
2State Farm$1,598
3Nationwide$2,005
4Progressive$2,049
5Allstate$2,779
6Farmers$3,074
2018

2018 Toyota 86 insurance rates

Average cost to insure $2,019
Annual cheapest rate $1,502
Available trims GT, Hakone Edition
RankCompanyAverage annual premium
1Geico$1,502
2State Farm$1,592
3Nationwide$2,048
4Progressive$2,060
5Farmers$2,417
6Allstate$2,497
2017

2017 Toyota 86 insurance rates

Average cost to insure $1,988
Annual cheapest rate $1,367
Available trims GT, Hakone Edition
RankCompanyAverage annual premium
1Geico$1,367
2State Farm$1,543
3Progressive$1,939
4Nationwide$2,097
5Allstate$2,485
6Farmers$2,496
x
What can we help you find?